The Interaction between Safety Culture and Degraded Modes:
نویسنده
چکیده
This paper presents the initial results from a study into the interaction between safety culture and degraded modes of operation in European Air Traffic Management (ATM). Degraded modes occur when operators struggle to maintain levels of service even though key elements of their infrastructure have failed. Safety culture can be simply described as ‘the way safety is done around here’ – emphasizing that it is concerned with the realities of safety, and not necessarily what people say should be done. Although safety culture therefore deals necessarily with attitudes, beliefs and even feelings – so called ‘soft’ phenomena – it does not mean that these are any less important than more objective and visible safety management artifacts such as standards and procedures etc. Poor safety culture is often linked to the causes of major accidents and incidents. Recent initiatives in Air Traffic Management, including the European Safety Programme and its precursor, the Strategic Safety Action Plan, have also recognized that degraded modes of operation played a significant role in previous adverse events. Operators often reveal a high degree of tolerance for degraded infrastructures. There is a “can do” attitude, whereby staff struggle to maintain operations when it might be more prudent to reduce the level of service or even close airspace in order to maintain levels of safety. The high level objectives of this project are: 1. to identify safety cultural aspects that influence tolerance to degraded modes and 2. to identify ‘best practices’ that Air Navigation Service Providers (ANSPs) can apply to deal with degraded mode of operations.
منابع مشابه
Understanding the Contribution of Degraded Modes of Operation as a Cause of Incidents and Accidents in Air Traffic Management
This paper charts the role that ‘degraded modes of operation’ have played in a number of recent accidents and incidents in European Air Traffic Management. A central aim of this analysis is to begin to understand why teams of co-workers continue to operate safety critical systems even when key elements of their technological infrastructure have been compromised, for example during routine maint...
متن کاملThe Contribution of Degraded Modes of Operation to Accidents in the US, UK and Australian Rail Industries
Degraded modes of operation occur when technological systems fail to meet the levels of service that are expected by staff and managers. Over time, operators develop ‘work arounds’ that help them to cope with these degraded modes. This has led to a culture of ‘making do’ where co-workers try their best to maintain service provision in spite of system failures. The extent to which operators will...
متن کاملA Comparison of the Role of Degraded Modes of Operation in the Causes of Accidents in Rail and Air Traffic Management
Degraded modes of operation occur when technological systems fail to meet the levels of service that are expected by staff and managers. Over time, operators develop ‘work arounds’ that help them to cope with these degraded modes. This has led to a culture of ‘making do’ where co-workers try their best to maintain service provision in spite of system failures. The extent to which operators will...
متن کاملDegraded Modes and the ‘Culture of Coping’ in Military Operations: An Analysis of a Fatal Incident On-Board HMS Tireless
In many military operations, weapons safety is compromised by 'degraded modes of operation'. These are situations in which personnel must find 'work arounds' for the many different routine failures that complicate military life. In most cases, these ad hoc adaptations do not threaten safety. However, if these failures are not addressed they can gradually erode the barriers and other defensive m...
متن کاملScaring Engineers with Degraded Modes: The Strengths and Weakness of Action Research in Air Traffic Management
Degraded modes of operation occur when operations and engineering teams work to maintain levels of service even though critical elements of their underlying technical infrastructure have failed. In most situations, these ‘work arounds’ and ad hoc fixes do not threaten safety. However, the Linate runway incursion and the berlingen mid-air collision have shown that degraded modes of operation com...
متن کامل